Ahh vital wheat gluten… Sometimes you really amaze me. Here you sit in a bulk bag from Whole Foods, a mere brownish powder. Yet even in this basic state I know that within the hour you will be as succulent and plump as… well, you get the picture.
A lot of people I know get hung up on the mechanics of making seitan. How much wet to dry? What if the stock boils?! To steam or to simmer… I think once you realize that seitan is, in essence, a pretty forgiving dough that really just wants to work with you, things will be a lot easier. Obviously the key to any successful batch of seitan is texture. Follow these simple steps and your cooking pot will yield juicy, savory seitan with texture magnifique. Served here with shallots and mushrooms in a rich pinot noir gravy, this gluten-centric entree is a real keeper.
First things first, get your seitan broth started. Combine in a large stock pot:
6 C water
1 C Mimiccreme
3 bay leaves
1/2 C dried porcini mushrooms
1 T Better Than Bouillon No Beef base
2 T tamari
1 t onion powder
1/2 t garlic powder
1/2 t salt
Bring to a boil, then reduce heat to med-low to maintain a simmer. While stock is heating up, prepare your seitan dough. In a cooking bowl combine
1 C vital wheat gluten
3/4 C water
1 T Mimiccreme
1 t Better Than Bouillon No Beef base dissolved in 1 T water
1 t red miso dissolved in 1 T water
Mix well with your hands, making sure to not overwork the dough. You’ll know if it’s becoming overworked if it starts to feel overly elastic and begins to resist stretching. If this occurs, don’t fret – just let dough sit on a cutting board for 10-15 mins; it can self-soothe. If you’ve made seitan before, this dough may seem a bit wetter than usual. The ideal consistency here is for the dough to be wet enough to stretch and be easily manipulated, but not so wet that it falls apart. When you’re satisfied with the consistency, cut dough into 4 “steaks” with a sharp knife.
Slip steaks into your cooking broth and cover the stock pot. Simmer for an hour, flipping every fifteen minutes or so. When the cutlets are finished remove them from the broth, and, when cooled, wrap them in paper towels and press well (as you would tofu); it’s imperative that you get out the excess cooking broth so they can absorb the flavors of the gravy. Here’s about what your raw steaks should look like.

At this time, get your seitan rub together. On a large plate, mix together:
1/2 C crushed raw cashews
1 T dried rosemary
3/4 C unbleached flour
1 t salt
1 t fresh ground white pepper
Rub each seitan steak with a 1/1 mixture of tamari and olive oil. Then dredge steaks in dry mix, making sure to coat evenly. Shake each steak to remove excess flour and set aside.
Next, begin preparing your gravy. Here’s what you’ll need:
2 T olive oil
2 shallots, thinly sliced
2 cloves garlic, minced
1/2 C mushrooms (I used lion’s mane, but cremini would work fine)
1 C pinot noir
1/2 C water, with 1 t No Beef bouillon dissolved
2 T Earth Balance (or other vegan margarine)
1 t corn starch dissolved in 1 T water
1 T fresh chopped thyme
salt and pepper to taste
Heat oil in a nonstick saucepan, add shallots, garlic and mushrooms and saute over medium heat until shallots are translucent. Add pinot noir and water and bring to a boil, then reduce heat to med-high, partially cover pot, and saute for ~5 mins. Stir in Earth Balance and dissolved corn starch and saute for an additional 2-3 mins. Add fresh thyme and salt and pepper to taste, stir well to mix, remove from heat and cover.
Coat a nonstick skillet with a thin layer of olive oil and begin to saute seitan steaks over medium heat. Cover skillet while steaks are cooking to make sure that they heat through. Saute until steaks are browned on both sides (3-4 mins per side). Top steaks with gravy and serve with some nice greens on the side.
